What Makes a Bad Newsletter?

photo credit
  1. No two newsletters are alike
  2. If you subscribe, it’s a good newsletter

No two newsletters are the same because no two audiences or topics are exactly the same.

Using examples of three newsletters I subscribe to:

  • Axios is quick and to the point, with few articles going beyond 400 words and few links to external sources. They use a graphic for every article in the bulletin.
  • The Hannah Arendt Center’s philosophy newsletter often has 1,500-word introductions to the longer articles on their website, to which they link. There is usually just one image in the entire newsletter.
  • Arts & Letters Daily is actually a weekly email with five of the best articles published on their website that week with one very short sentence describing each essay. You can read everything without scrolling.

Two totally different topics — daily news and philosophy — so therefore two totally different newsletters!

  • It’s easy enough to compare/contrast any two newsletters you receive.

How do I know that the 20+ newsletters I subscribe to aren’t BAD?

  • Because I haven’t unsubscribed from them!
  • They’re doing their job…for me.

A bad newsletter:

  • doesn’t understand the audience,
  • isn’t consistent with its content, tone, aesthetics, etc,
  • isn’t clear about what the reader should do with the info,
  • is irregularly delivered, and
  • is ugly

Simply put, if you haven’t unsubscribed, then the newsletter is at least good enough for what you need.

Remember that when you’re designing your employee newsletter…and then do it much better 😉.

Mister Editorial Articles About Newsletters

Subscribe to my newsletter.




Many internal comms teams don’t have an editorial strategy. I’m here to fix that. Newsletter: https://mistereditorial.substack.com/.

Love podcasts or audiobooks? Learn on the go with our new app.

Recommended from Medium

Product Adoption Lifecycle for Music Streaming Services in India

Gaana was the most popular music streaming app among Indians surveyed between January and February 2020. JioSaavn followed with Wynk in third place. Of an average 65 minutes spent listening to music, however, Spotify held the top spot during the survey period.

How to Use LinkedIn for Marketing — And Get Leads

What is a Customer Persona? — Lydia Sciarrino Consulting

Online Marketing Tools to Start a Business you must know (Part 1)

How is Memphis Meats doing during this nightmare?!

COVID-19 Opportunities: Digitally Engaging Donors Where They Are

Five key metrics to monitor your subscription business success

I always say, “Every story has a design”.

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Mister Editorial

Mister Editorial

Many internal comms teams don’t have an editorial strategy. I’m here to fix that. Newsletter: https://mistereditorial.substack.com/.

More from Medium

Toxic Productivity & Comparison Culture’s impact on University Students

The Challenge of Turning Your Knowledge into Action

What if We Trained Our Attention the Way We Train Our Bodies?

Is consistent productivity one of the biggest challenges of a creative career?

Photo by Лилия Крутько from Pexels